The Standard American Diet: What is it and Where do we go Next?
Table of Contents
- What is the Standard American Diet?
- What the DGA Gets Wrong
- The Standard American Diet in the Context of Human Evolution
- The Standard American Diet and The Diseases of Civilization
- SAD and Heart Disease
- SAD and Diabetes
- SAD and Cancer
- SAD and Inflammatory Bowel Diseases
- SAD and Infertility
- Imbalance of omega-6 over omega-3 in the Standard American Diet
- High-Fat Low-Carb: An Alternative to the Standard American Diet
What is the Standard American Diet?
The Standard American Diet (SAD) is a term used to describe the macro and micronutrient composition of the food Americans eat. It’s based on a consensus of mainstream nutrition experts drawing on data from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES).
The Nutritional Examination Survey (NHANES)
The NHANES is an ongoing national study that surveys participating Americans about their diets.
According to the 2017-2018 NHANES data, the average American adult eats:
- 2100 calories a day,
- 16% of those calories from protein,
- 47% from carbohydrate
- 36% from fat.
- 22% of all calories from added sugars
The following graph shows the distribution of the total energy intake along with the energy intake from added sugars according to food groups, and the content of added sugars in each food group.
|Mean energy intake||Mean energy intake from added sugars||Mean content of added sugars|
|Food groups||Absolute (kcal/day)||Relative (% of total energy intake)||Absolute (kcal/day)||Relative (% of total energy intake from added sugars)||Percentage of energy from added sugars|
|Unprocessed or minimally processed foods||585.5||29.6||0.0||0.0||0.0|
|Meat (includes poultry)||165.3||7.9||0.0||0.0||0.0|
|Milk and plain yoghurt||96.4||5.1||0.0||0.0||0.0|
|Roots and tubers||32.2||1.6||0.0||0.0||0.0|
|Fish and sea food||17.2||0.8||0.0||0.0||0.0|
|Other unprocessed or minimally processed foods†||36.7||1.8||0.0||0.0||0.0|
|Processed culinary ingredients||64.3||2.9||24.4||8.7||38.8|
|Other processed culinary ingredients¶||0.9||0.04||0.0||0.0||0.0|
|Unprocessed or minimally processed foods+processed culinary ingredients||649.8||32.6||24.4||8.7||3.7|
|Ham and other salted, smoked or canned meat or fish||26.4||1.2||0.3||0.2||1.4|
|Vegetables and other plant foods preserved in brine||13.4||0.7||1.6||0.9||13.7|
|Other processed foods**||89.8||3.8||0.6||0.5||1.2|
|Cakes, cookies and pies||122.8||5.7||29.8||11.2||24.2|
|Frozen and shelf-stable plate meals||80.6||4.02||1.1||0.7||1.6|
|Soft drinks, carbonated||81.8||3.7||75.2||17.1||69.9|
|Sauces, dressings and gravies||49.8||2.4||4.4||2.8||10.0|
|Reconstituted meat or fish products||51.5||2.4||0.7||0.6||2.0|
|Ice cream and ice pops||48.7||2.3||18.3||5.9||36.9|
|French fries and other potato products||37.8||1.7||0.0||0.0||0.0|
|Sandwiches and hamburgers on bun (ready-to-eat/heat)||32.5||1.4||1.3||0.6||4.4|
|Instant and canned soups||14.3||0.8||0.1||0.1||0.7|
|Other ultra-processed foods†††||81.5||3.8||3.1||1.5||7.8|
In addition, the federal Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee analyzes the NHANES data and current nutritional research and creates the Dietary Guidelines for Americans (DGA).
Dietary Guidelines for Americans (DGA)
The overall goal of the DGA is to advise people on what to eat to promote good health and prevent disease. This is where the USDA Food Pyramid comes from, and the more recent MyPlate graphic. These guides are supposed to positively influence the Standard American Diet.
The first DGA was released in 1980 and it gets updated every five years. The current 2020-2025 version hasn’t changed much. It still advises Americans to eat less fat and more carbohydrates for good health, despite a great deal of research that contradicts that advice.
The DGA and The Standard American Diet
The DGA sets the ideals for what is healthy eating and then compares those ideals to the Standard American Diet.
The DGA says that Americans should eat fresh fruits and vegetables, whole grains, lean protein and healthy oils for good health.
When the SAD is compared to this ideal, the DGA says we eat too much-saturated fat in the form of red meat and high-fat dairy products, too much fast food, and too many refined carbohydrates, added sugars, salt, and overall calories.
These less than ideal choices, they report, are why so many Americans suffer from the chronic diseases of obesity, heart disease, diabetes and cancer. As we shall see, some of these DGA charges are supported in scientific evidence, but not all.
For instance, relying on fast food for most meals does increase calorie, salt, and sugar intakes substantially, while reducing vitamin and mineral intakes needed for good health. This is especially true for younger Americans.
However, the research shows that only about 37% of adults eat fast food regularly. In fact, as shown by the USDA Healthy Eating Index, a measure of diet quality, American adults make “healthy” food choices about 60-65% of the time.
That means for a majority of meals, Americans follow the Dietary Guidelines. Yet, the problem of chronic diseases in the US continues to worsen. Let’s explore why this is the case.
What the DGA Gets Wrong
The Nutrition Coalition, a respected group of dietary professionals, identifies the answer for the increase of chronic disease in America as rooted in the DGA’s recommendation to eat less fat and more carbohydrates.
They contend that the Dietary Committee has ignored research clearly indicating that too much dietary carbohydrate is the main cause for the current health problems plaguing Americans.
They recommend that a low-carbohydrate diet would be healthier for the American population, especially when considering that 60 percent of Americans already suffer from metabolic disorders. Metabolic disorders refer to disruptions in the normal processes of breaking down food into its nutrient parts–fat, protein, sugar, vitamins, and minerals. High intake of carbohydrates is a primary factor for many of these disorders.
Yet the DGA Committee chose to largely ignore these studies as they debated the 2015 and the 2020 Guideline publications. The current MyPlate graphic shows that the DGA still recommends most Americans get most of their calories from plant-based carbohydrates.
A Shift Away from Low-Fat Recommendations
To their credit, the DGA Committee did finally admit the low-fat diet they had been pushing for years was not supported scientifically. They also relaxed their recommendations for consuming less cholesterol. And they admitted that there was “no appreciable relationship” between dietary cholesterol and blood cholesterol levels.
In an article for the New York Times, Nina Teicholz, the director of the Nutrition Coalition writes “Americans, it seems, had needlessly been avoiding egg yolks, liver and shellfish for decades.” Teicholz’s concern over how the DGA “experts” got our dietary advice wrong for so long calls into question the current DGA’s advice.
Standard American Diet Fast Facts
- The USDA Dietary Guidelines for Americans defines the standard American diet (SAD) as being too low in fresh fruits and vegetables, whole grains, lean protein, and healthy oils, and too high in red meat, high-fat dairy products, processed and fast foods, refined carbohydrates, added sugars, salt, and calories.
- The SAD was not the diet humans evolved eating.
- For hundreds of thousands of years, all humans were hunter-gatherers who ate mostly fatty meats, supplemented with low nutrient plant foods.
- The SAD is not compatible with our genetic heritage.
- Eating a Standard American DIet is a root cause of the “diseases of civilization.”
- Diseases of civilization include heart disease, diabetes, cancer, infertility, mental health issues, and other metabolic diseases.
- A solution to the health problems introduced by the standard American diet may be to adopt a low carb diet high in whole animal based foods.
The Standard American Diet in the Context of Human Evolution
When we look at the origins of SAD, we see that it is a modern aberration in the human race’s dietary history. For millions of years, mankind ate almost no carbohydrates. It’s only in the recent past that we have made carbs the center of our daily meals.
From Meat to Carbs
The modern human (homo sapiens) race, according to science’s best guess, evolved into being about 200,000 years ago. But our ancient ancestors were walking the earth much earlier.
The first humanoid animals depended on a plant-based diet and had brains no larger than a chimpanzee. At about 2.5 million years ago, Paleolithic man learned to scavenge meat from other predator kills. With the addition of that nutritionally-dense food, human brains and digestive systems began to change.
Over the next few million years, our ancestors developed tools that helped them become true hunters, and as the amount of meat they consumed increased, brain size and cognitive ability expanded.
Around 100,000 years ago, humans had learned to throw a spear with speed and accuracy and to catch and cook seafood. That meat-rich diet, high in nutritional resources for brain growth, resulted in the human ability to speak and think abstractly, trade with others, create art and clothes, and migrate across continents to find more food and better places to live.
After only a few thousand years of agriculture, (between 8000-3000 BC) much of the human population had stopped wandering after wild animal herds and started settling into life as Neolithic farmers. We began domesticating animals and growing and eating cereal grains such as wheat and corn.
Plant Foods, Carbs, and Disease in Human History
As ancient humans began to consume more cereal grains and less meat, bone health and resistance to disease began to deteriorate.
Studies of early Neolithic human remains show that by 3000 BC, farmers were several inches shorter than hunter-gatherers and their bones and teeth show evidence of mineral disorders such as rickets and osteoporosis.
There were also indications of severe vitamin and mineral deficiencies and a proliferation of infectious diseases. In addition, evidence indicates infant mortality rates were high, and the average span of a farmer’s life was shorter too.
Our Modern Diet
And so here we are. After more than two million years of a diet rich in animal protein and fat, modern humans switched to eating cereal grains in an evolutionary microsecond.
And in the last nanosecond of 200 years, we added refined carbohydrates and industrial oils to our diets.
Unfortunately for us, our genetic adaptation process works on a million-year time frame, so our genetic profile is pretty much the same as it was 200,000 years ago. Hence, we are experiencing the collective health costs of eating a diet we are not genetically equipped to handle. This is quite clear if we look at the current health data and note the prevalence of the “diseases of civilization”.
The Standard American Diet and The Diseases of Civilization
The phrase “diseases of civilization” refers to how in first-world, wealthy countries, the manner in which people eat and live causes them to die from chronic diseases such as diabetes, cancer, inflammatory conditions and heart disease.
Much of the current research supports the assertion that refined carbohydrate consumption is the main culprit in the proliferation of these disease states, in large part because high blood sugar increases body inflammation, which triggers other disease processes. More on this later.
SAD and Inflammation
Inflammation is a condition in which a person’s immune system has been triggered to fight some sort of irritation or damage taking place within their body.
For example, an immune system response is what causes the pain and redness around the area of a splinter in one’s finger. If the offending cause is not removed, the immune system response and the associated inflammation itself can eventually become a chronic condition which causes further damage.
Chronic inflammation is implicated in a wide variety of diseases including heart disease, metabolic syndrome, and diabetes, cancer, autoimmune conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis, infertility, and mental disorders such as depression.
One of the main triggers for chronic inflammation in the body is rampant glycation. This is a process where the sugar molecules in the bloodstream stick to our cells and tissues.
A small amount of glycation is normal and can easily be repaired by the body. But when a person’s daily diet includes large amounts of carbohydrates, blood sugars become chronically high, glycation rates increase, and a chain reaction of damage is set off that results in increased inflammation.
SAD and Heart Disease
The carb-fueled inflammatory process is one of the main factors linking the standard American diet to cardiovascular disease.
Cardiovascular disease is typically associated with damage to the body’s vascular system. This system of blood vessels brings oxygenated blood from the lungs to the heart and other body systems.
As inflammation sets into those injured areas, a loss of vessel suppleness leads to high blood pressure. Further injury leads to atherosclerosis (the infamous “hardening of the arteries”) and vascular blockages which can trigger a heart attack and stroke.
SAD and Diabetes
The high carb intake of The Standard American Diet contributes to diabetes by spiking insulin levels and increasing Inflammation. Diabetes is one of the most damaging diseases of civilization. People with diabetes can no longer manage the amount of sugar in the bloodstream.
In 2018, the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) reported that more than 34 million Americans had diabetes. Type 2 diabetes is the most common by far and is strongly linked to refined and total carbohydrate consumption. Both staples of the Standard American Diet.
The human body is not designed to handle consistently high amounts of sugar. Eating carbs for three meals a day with snacks in between floods the bloodstream in toxic levels of glucose. This constant stream of glucose stresses the adrenal glands and stimulates your pancreas to produce the hormone insulin in excessive amounts.
Over time, increased levels of blood sugar and insulin result in high levels of glycation and inflammation which trigger more widespread damage including:
- loss of eyesight
- kidney failure
- nerve damage
- heart disease
- serious infections
SAD and Cancer
The high carb intake of the standard American diet is also a factor in the development of cancer.
In short, eating a SAD diet high in refined carbohydrates sets up conditions in the body that encourage the establishment and growth of cancer.
An important point to note here is that the USDA Dietary Guidelines advise that red meat consumption should be limited because it is linked to cancer in many epidemiological studies.
However, a meta-analysis of the research on the relationship of red meat consumption to cancer mortality was published in 2019 and concluded that the “possible effects of red and processed meat consumption on cancer mortality and incidence are very small and the certainty of evidence is low to very low.”
SAD and Inflammatory Bowel Diseases
The carbohydrate-rich standard American diet is also strongly linked to inflammation within the intestinal system.
The intestinal tract is home to billions of gut bacteria collectively termed the gut microbiota.
This ecosystem of organisms helps us digest our food while protecting against foreign toxins. It’s also responsible for producing essential vitamins and neurotransmitters.
The Standard American Diet afflicts the gut when sugar, fiber, and plant toxins damage cells lining the intestinal tract. The immune system responds to the damage with an inflammatory response that destroys gut bacteria. This allows the infiltration of toxic organisms which encourages further inflammation.
Wheat gluten and other cereal grains and flours are major offenders in gut cell damage and inflammatory bowel conditions. Several studies report that foods high in fermentable carbohydrates (FODMAPS) worsen irritable bowel conditions.
Although red meat consumption is often cited as a factor in bowel diseases, little controlled research data exists to support this hypothesis. At least one controlled study shows that reducing red meat intake does not reduce the rate of Crohn’s disease flare-ups.
SAD and Infertility
Another body system that’s sensitive to the high carbs and plant toxins in the Standard American Diet is the reproductive system.
Research confirms that high blood sugars can increase the amount of glycation and oxidative stress within the reproductive organs. This results in reduced ovarian function and dysfunction in the granulosa cells which protect egg development.
High levels of glycation also reduce the activity of female steroid production and follicular development in the ovaries. And finally, glycation and oxidative stress also cause damage to the capability of male testicles to produce normal sperm cells.
Imbalance of omega-6 over omega-3 in the Standard American Diet
The standard American diet also causes an imbalance of essential fatty acids. You’ve probably heard the term omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids during commercials for fish oil supplements. But what are these substances and why are they important in our diet?
Omega-3 and omega-6 essential fatty acids (EFA) are “essential” because they cannot be synthesized by the body and must be derived from dietary sources. They are also polyunsaturated, a term that refers to the types of chemical bonds within the molecules.
Fats like butter and coconut oil have stable chemical bonds called “saturated” bonds and so are called saturated fats. Olive oil has one unstable bond and is a monounsaturated fatty acid or MUFA. But omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids have multiple unstable chemical bonds, so they fall in the category of polyunsaturated fatty acids or PUFA.
We only need a small amount of PUFA each day, but they are vitally important as they play a role in nearly every metabolic function in the body. And each type of essential fatty acid has different effects on body systems, as shown in the graphic below.
Eicosanoids and Inflammation
Essential fatty acids are also sources for the body’s production of a class of hormone-like molecules called eicosanoids.
These molecules are among the most potent regulators of cellular function, and they are produced by almost every cell in the body. Eicosanoids exert a wide-ranging and profound influence on your health. Among other important effects, they regulate blood pressure, lung function, and blood clotting mechanisms.
The type of eicosanoids that are dominant within the body depends on the types of essential fatty acids being consumed in the daily diet. In general, since omega-3 fatty acids have an anti-inflammatory effect on the body, eating more omega-3 rich foods results in an accumulation of anti-inflammatory eicosanoids. In contrast, eating more omega-6 fatty acids results in an increase of eicosanoids which have pro-inflammatory properties.
Decline in Omega-3s
In the last 100 years, the amount of omega-3 polyunsaturated fats in the Western diet has declined while the consumption of omega-6 fatty acids has increased substantially. This is due to the development and use of vegetable and seed oils in our food supply.
The USDA advises Americans that vegetable and seed oils (olive oil, soybean oil, canola oil, and sunflower oil) are healthy fats, but it neglects to mention these oils are highly processed industrial products.
Not only are they high in inflammatory omega-6 fatty acids, but their production process introduces other toxins such as hexane and pesticides into the final product. Almost all processed foods contain one or more vegetable oils.
The abundance of omega-6 oils in the standard American diet tilts it toward being pro-inflammatory, and not surprisingly, research links an imbalance of omega-3 to omega-6 fatty acids to a long list of chronic disease, including heart disease, cancer, diabetes, and other metabolic diseases , pregnancy issues and mood disorders such as depression and bipolar disorder.
How the Standard American Diet Affects Mental Health
The body of research on the relationship between mental health and diet continues to grow, and it supports the hypothesis that not only is a deficiency of anti-inflammatory fatty acids such as EPA involved, but that oxidative stress can be a trigger for mental issues as well.
Many psychiatric disorders can be linked to issues with the optimal amounts of brain neurotransmitters such as serotonin and dopamine. Julia Ross, MA is the author of a book called the Diet Cure, and she lays out the evidence for how blood sugar instability and fatty acid deficiencies can impair our brain chemistry. Other research points to the link between refined carbohydrate intake, gut health, and psychological disorders.
High-Fat Low-Carb: An Alternative to the Standard American Diet
To improve our health, we now know that most Americans should avoid the high blood sugars, inflammation, gut microbiota damage, and fatty-acid imbalances characteristic of the consumption of too many carbohydrates and processed oils. So what do we eat instead?
A ketogenic, high-fat, low-carbohydrate diet fits the prescription nicely. It reduces not only refined but total carbohydrate intake. HFLC eating also encourages the consumption of healthy, natural fats and fresh meats and seafood. The result is a diet moderate in protein, low in carbohydrate, and rich in good fats.
The health benefits of a ketogenic diet include lower blood sugar and insulin levels, less glycation and inflammation, support for optimal brain function, and a reduction in the likelihood of developing or worsening heart disease, cancer or a metabolic disease such as diabetes.
The outlook on the Standard American Diet
For many Americans, the Standard American Diet’s reliance on carbohydrates, especially refined carbohydrates as our main source of calories does not promote good health.
The Standard American Diet increases body inflammation and triggers blood sugar and glycation issues that foster diseases such as heart disease, cancer, and diabetes.
In addition, relying on processed foods high in Omega-6 fatty acids upsets our essential fatty acid balance which can contribute to inflammation, and result in brain chemical derangement, mental health disorders.
Fortunately, we now have research to support the choice of a high-fat, low-carb diet to help us avoid or reverse many of these “diseases of civilization” and help us stay healthier for the duration of our lives.
Now we’re all waiting for the USDA Dietary Guidelines committee to get on board with the current research and provide the American public with science-based nutrition advice.